erhardt's blog

When Identities Turn Violent

Facing History and Ourselves hosted a Day of Learning "Reimagining Self and Others" at Harvard Law School on May 10, 2013. This is a summary of the "When Identities Turn Violent" segment featuring historian of genocide Omer Bartov and sociologist of religion Jose Casanova.

Anthony Appiah on the Ethics of Diversity

Facing History and Ourselves hosted a Day of Learning "Reimagining Self and Others" at Harvard Law School on May 10, 2013. This is a liveblog of the opening presentation by Anthony Appiah, a philosopher at Princeton University, whose latest book is The Honor Code: How Moral Revolutions Happen.

Appiah begins by framing the ethics of diversity with motivating questions that go back to Aristotle's ethics: 1) What is it for a life to go well? 2) What is human well-being? These are tied to Aristotle's concept of eudaimonia, which is poorly translated as 'happiness' but is more robust, representing the successful life, or flourishing life.

To work through the ethics of diversity, Appiah suggests three ethical principles:

  1. Everybody matters (this was not true in Aristotle's Athens, he only spoke of free, adult males)
  2. We owe everyone respect for their human dignity: we must bear in mind the facts about them that should shape how we treat them
  3. Each person is in charge of managing his or her own life

Transnational Dimensions of Spreadable Media

Liveblog of the MiT8 panel on Transnational Dimensions of Spreadable Media moderated by Sam Ford. Notes with Rodrigo Davies and others.

Nancy Baym, Music Without Borders: Globalization and its Contents

Nancy introduces two current, competing frames of music consumers: Pirates vs Customers. We ask, are musicians getting paid enough? But the question frames musicians as producers, as manufacturers.

How do musicians understand their interactions and relationships with their audiences? How have social media affected these things? What is the broader system of values into which money fits?

Philosophy and Civic Engagement

Last Friday, April 26, 2013, I attended the Philosophy and Civic Engagement symposium at Tufts University. Three speakers looked at different philosophical aspects of civic engagement: Anthony Laden of the University of Illinois at Chicago discussed the importance of reasoning as a social, interactive practice in democratic citizenship, Meira Levinson of Harvard Graduate School of Education investigated the pros and cons of redefining civic action beyond public activities, and Peter Levine of Tufts University and CIRCLE discussed the philosophical aspects of his forthcoming book: We Are the Ones We Have Been Waiting For. Below are my notes from their talks.

All the Lawyers Agree: There is a Crisis in Civics

On Monday, I attended the conference Civics Education: Why it Matters to Democracy, Society and You co-presented by Harvard Law School and the Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools. I liveblogged all four panels for the Center for Civic Media:Logo from the iCivics game 'We the Jury'

I want to summarize some of the key points made by panelists and in questions from the audience. But more importantly, I want to respond to what I think were some glaring omissions in the discussion.

How can we encourage youth to participate in democracy?

Liveblog of the fourth and final panel of the conference Civics Education: Why it Matters to Democracy, Society and You at Harvard Law School, April 1, 2013. Willow Brugh contributed to these notes.

PANEL 4: Engagement: How can we encourage youth to participate in democracy? #vizthink by @willowbl00
(#vizthink by @willowbl00)

Panelists:

  • Meira Levinson (Professor & Co-convener, HGSE Civic and Moral Education Initiative, Harvard Graduate School of Education)
  • Diana Hess (Professor, University of Wisconsin-Madison)
  • Scott Warren (Executive Director, Generation Citizen)
  • Justin Reich (Director of Online Community, Practice and Research at Facing History and Ourselves, Harvard University)
  • Richard Freeland (Commissioner of Higher Education for Massachusetts)
  • Carlos Rojas (Education Policy Associate, Youth on Board)
  • Moderator: Richard Weissbourd (Lecturer in Education, Harvard Graduate School of Education)

What's at stake? Why civic matters to me, and to you

Liveblog of the third panel of the conference Civics Education: Why it Matters to Democracy, Society and You at Harvard Law School, April 1, 2013. Willow Brugh contributed to these notes.

PANEL 3: What’s at stake? Why civic matters to me, and to you

Panelists:

  • Justice Sandra Day O’Connor (former Associate Justice, Supreme Court of the United States)
  • Justice David Souter (former Associate Justice, Supreme Court of the United States)
  • Judge Kenneth Starr (President, Baylor University)
  • Larry Tribe (Professor, Harvard Law School)
  • Moderator: Martha Minow (Dean, Harvard Law School)

MM: The bet of the democracy is that we can govern ourselves. The risk is that we will not be prepared to do so. [Introduces Sandra Day O’Connor] She has dedicated herself most recently to looking at the critical role of education in democracy. Why have you decided to make this such an important focus of your attention?

What barriers stand in the way of better civic learning?

Liveblog of the second panel of the conference Civics Education: Why it Matters to Democracy, Society and You at Harvard Law School, April 1, 2013. Willow Brugh contributed to these notes.

#vizthink by willowbl00
(#vizthink by willowbl00)

Panelists:

  • Under Secretary Martha Kanter (Under Secretary, U.S. Department of Education)
  • David Hiller (President & CEO, McCormick Foundation)
  • Gene Koo (Executive Director, iCivics)
  • Kathleen McCartney (Dean of the Faculty of Education, Harvard Graduate School of Education)
  • Mabel McKinney-Browning (Director, Division for Public Education at American Bar Association)
  • Moderator: Chief Justice Margaret Marshall (former Justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court)

What should young Americans know about democracy?

Liveblog of the first panel of the conference Civics Education: Why it Matters to Democracy, Society and You at Harvard Law School, April 1, 2013.

#vizthink by @willowbl00
(#vizthink by @willowbl00)

Panelists:

  • State Senator Richard Moore (Massachusetts State Senator)
  • Howard Gardner (Professor, Harvard Graduate School of Education)
  • Peter Levine (Professor, Tufts University and Director of CIRCLE)
  • Robert Gallucci (President, MacArthur Foundation)
  • Romero Brown (Vice President of Program & Youth Development Services, Boys and Girls Club)
  • Moderator: Tomiko Brown-Nagin (Professor, Harvard Law School)

Susan Crawford's Captive Audience Talk at the MIT Media Lab

Liveblog of Susan Crawford talking about her new book Captive Audience: The Telecom Industry and Monopoly Power in the New Gilded Age at the Media Lab Conversations Series.

Molly Sauter contributed to this liveblog, and Rodrigo Davies previously posted our transcription of the Q&A portion of the event.

Introduction and Biography
Susan Crawford was at the Media Lab today to talk about her new book Captive Audience: The Telecom Industry and Monopoly Power in the New Gilded Age. She is a highly-respected lawyer and professor and has taught at Cardozo Law School, University of Michigan, Yale, and now Harvard Law School. She was on Obama's transition team reviewing the FCC, and a special advisor to Obama Administration on Innovation and Tech policy. She is also a former board member of ICANN and founder of OneWebDay.

Pages