Andrew's blog

Communications Forum featuring NPR's Juan Williams: "Race, Politics, and American Media"

The election of an African-American president in November 2008 has been hailed as a transforming event. But has Obama's ascension transformed anything? Many people's answer to that question changed this summer when a famous Harvard professor was arrested at his home in Cambridge. Are the harsh realities of race and class in the U.S. clearer now or murkier, following the media tsunami of Gatesgate? And has this polarizing event given greater visibility to racial minorities in the media's coverage of politics? How are race issues and racial politics covered in our national media, and what are the implications of the demise of major city newspapers for the coverage of race and politics?

Juan Williams of NPR and Fox News discussed these and related questions in a candid conversation with Phillip Thompson, associate professor of urban politics in the Department of Urban Studies and Planning at MIT, and David Thorburn, Professor of Literature and Director of the MIT Communications Forum. This forum is the first of two this term in our ongoing civic media series, a collaboration of the Communications Forum and the Media Lab's Center for Future Civic Media.

An audio version is also available via the CMS Colloquium Podcast in the iTunes Store.

Newsfail: No major newspapers able or willing to cover catastrophic floods in Atlanta

With the exception of the beleaguered Atlanta Journal-Constitution, no major papers are covering the flooding currently ravaging Atlanta, Georgia. I only know about it because my mother and step-father live there---they're fine, but my mother nearly couldn't get home last night because of so many downed trees, washed-out roads, and police barricades. My step-father, being ex-Special Forces, was ridiculously well-prepared (hurricane lamps, a universal charger for multiple cell phones that hooks up to his car's cigarette lighter), but their neighbors aren't so lucky: good friends of theirs have seen their house so damaged that they expect to live in a hotel for months.

On trust, eight years after 9/11

Something that characterizes everyone I've met in my year at the Center for Future Civic Media is a visceral frustration with tools and schemes that chip away at community ties or shut down communication between friends and neighbors---contrasted with an earnest desire to use technology to engender trust, heal rifts, and collectively build a better future. For every soul-crushing "See Something, Say Something" campaign, someone's working on a Hero Reports to counteract it.

On this, the eighth anniversary of 9/11, it's worth reflecting on this frustration and this desire to reestablish trust.

My in-laws are New Yorkers, and for many years my father-in-law worked in the World Trade Center. He was further uptown that morning, but, when the attacks happened, he made his way downtown to search for his nephew---who at that moment was escaping the WTC subway station through train tunnels. He was on the last train to leave before the towers fell. Together they walked up Manhattan island. They crossed a bridge into Brooklyn, turned back a moment, and recognized that their lives and their city were irreparably different.

So if anyone should want their government to guarantee safety at any cost, it's New Yorkers like them.

But as these eight years have gone by (admittedly perhaps because of a lack of new attacks), they have come to resent the breakdown in community particularly in contrast to the camaraderie felt in the immediate aftermath of 9/11, camaraderie despite fear of that next attack that we were all sure was coming. Sadly, it's human nature, and in the nature of government, to be influenced more by fear than by trust, and it's an old story. To act with perfect rationality in the wake of 9/11 would have been like Achilles not flipping out after Hector slays Patroclus. But Achilles, distraught, is who led us in our day to confused wars, sacrificed liberties, and, worst, a loss of trust in one another.

On this anniversary, I look with quite a bit of pride at our Center's long list of impressive projects in the context of reanimating that trust. It's the practice at MIT that we develop technologies to address really specific puzzles, but each of those technologies can be and are expanded to other contexts, ones that build up relationships between and within geographic communities:

  • The aforementioned Hero Reports helps people praise acts of civic courage before they're forgotten.
  • Extract organizes landowners---both urban and rural---so that they can represent their best interests to oil and gas companies.
  • The technology behind VirtualGaza, though focused on Palestinians, can be adapted to help communities in the midst of crisis when mapping and storytelling is most critical.
  • Newer projects, like Between the Bars, exemplify how a narrow cause---building a system that allows prisoners to blog---establishes a template for mutually beneficial relationships between groups that are usually adversarial.
  • And even ostensibly geek-centric work, like GoodApp, a cloud-computing environment to collaboratively develop web applications, means that a tool now exists for anyone---citizen, company, government---to build and share code, easily and transparently.

None of those projects works without a high level of trust, even between complete strangers. It's not a naive trust. Not one, childishly, where you renounce responsibility. It's one where you respect your neighbor, acknowledge his or her worth and talents, and know that you're stronger together than apart.

It's the lesson we learned eight years ago, and it's one to which the Center stays true.

Help the Knight Foundation promote the 2010 News Challenge

From our good friends and sponsors at the Knight Foundation, spreading the word on 2010 News Challenge. Use the code below to place a badge on your own website.

The 2010 News Challenge is accepting applications from now until October 15.

You can help us promote the 2010 News Challenge by putting a banner on your web site or blog. Click here for a page with images and html code which you can copy and paste.

URL: http://www.newschallenge.org/sites/default/files/knc-banner-for-icfj-280...
Click Now to Visit the Knight News Challenge
Code for your web page:

URL: http://www.newschallenge.org/sites/default/files/knc-bannerknc-170px.gif
Click Now to Visit the Knight News Challenge
Code for your web page:
German Language
banner_knc_german_468x60.gif (468px x 60px)
banner_knc_german_150x200.gif (150px x 200px)
banner_knc_german_120x90.gif (120px x 90px)
Spanish Language
banner_knc_spanish_468x60_v2.gif (468px x 60px)
banner_knc_spanish_150x200_v2.gif (150px x 200px)
banner_knc_spanish_120x90_v2.gif (120px x 90px)
Portuguese Language
banner_knc_portuguese_468x60.gif (468px x 60px)
banner_knc_portuguese_150x200.gif (150px x 200px)
banner_knc_portuguese_120x90.gif (120px x 90px)

Note: If you want us to know that you're sharing the love by sending traffic our way, change the value "&source=banner" to &source="your_name" and you'll know we can see which friends are linking to us.

LabCAST #40: The Future of News

Courtesy of the Media Lab's great production crew comes a great set of quick interviews with attendees of our Future of News and Civic Media conference.

Available for download as well: http://labcast.media.mit.edu/?p=90

LabCAST #40: The Future of News

Courtesy of the Media Lab's great production crew comes a great set of quick interviews with attendees of our Future of News and Civic Media conference.

Available for download as well: http://labcast.media.mit.edu/?p=90

Matthew Zachary discusses how to combat click-through activism

Our director Chris Csikszentmihályi recently described for the Washington Post what he calls "click-through activism", the propensity of people online, especially youth, to feel they are contributing to a cause simply by writing a tweet or adding their name to a Facebook cause page.

In some ways, [Csikszentmihályi] says, the ease of the medium "reminds me of dispensations the Catholic Church used to give." Worst-case scenario: If people feel they are doing good just by joining something -- or clicking on one of those become a fan of Audi and the company will offset your carbon emissions campaigns, "to what extent are you removing just enough pressure that they're not going to carry on the spark" in real life?

I was curious how click-through activism affects a national group whose organizing is done almost entirely online. So I approached Matthew Zachary---founder and CEO of I'm Too Young for This!, an online community and non-profit for young adult cancer survivors---for his thoughts.

Collaboration contest, at the Future of News and Civic Media conference

From the Future of News and Civic Media Conference, June 17-19 2009, co-hosted by MIT's Center for Future Civic Media and the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.

One of the little gems that the Knight Foundation introduced at the Future of News and Civic Media conference last week was to award five grand to the best collaborative projects created at the conference. We thought it might be a tall order, what with everything else the attendees were doing, but boy did they ever respond.

Collaboration contest, at the Future of News and Civic Media conference

MIT Tech TV

From the Future of News and Civic Media Conference, June 17-19 2009, co-hosted by MIT's Center for Future Civic Media and the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.

Pages